I’m closing in on completing a middle-grade novel revision and even though I’ve re-worked and polished plenty of manuscripts prior to this one, I think this is my first true revision.
(Whoa. My FIRST one?! That seems kinda . . . pathetic!)
I feel like I finally “get” certain advice for revising that I’ve often heard before–whether at writers’ conferences or from friends or from books. I’m sure you know the advice I mean–things like Jane Yolen saying revision means RE-visioning your story. Tons of writers and editors repeating that true revision is much more than polishing, or even than improving the flow of the story, or fleshing it out.
So many editors and agents at conferences mention finding promising manuscripts that need work. They offer some revision notes, and then their hearts sink when the writer shoots the “revised” work back to them a week or two later. (::coughs nervously . . . Ahem! Not that I know anything about that.::)
Or they tell the flip-side–the happier ending story. I remember hearing agent Tracey Adams recounting one of these experiences. I’ve forgotten who the writer was, but Ms. Adams critiqued her manuscript at a conference, then asked to see the whole thing, then offered revision notes. And she didn’t hear another word from that writer for . . . I think it was six months. Maybe a year? Anyhoo– the writer had read the notes and then thought about them for weeks and then realized she had to re-write her whole manuscript. From scratch. When it came back to Adams Literary, they were thrilled to offer her representation.
Not that I now think all manuscripts have to be completely re-written. And I’m sure that as you progress as a writer, the draft that intially comes out is closer and closer to your original vision. At least, I like to think so. ::whimpers::
But as I wind up a revision that included so much re-writing I feel like I’ve written a new manuscript, even though the core of the story is the same, I feel like a big wave of OHHHHH! I get it now! has finally washed over me. It’s exciting. Exhausting too, but mostly exciting.











